Mom's Pressure Cooker Chicken Cacciatore
Pressure cooker chicken cacciatore
Excerpted from Shabbos Under Pressure, by Sharon Matten, Feldheim Publishing. This pressure cooker Chicken Cacciatore recipe has become a KosherEye favorite! Comforting & Delicious!


1 tablespoon canola oil
1 large sweet onion (like Vidalia), cut in half and thinly sliced
2 cloves garlic, minced
1 pound white button mushrooms, sliced
2 cups flour (can be gluten free)
1 tablespoon onion powder
1 tablespoon garlic powder
1 and 1/2 teaspoons paprika
1/2 teaspoon freshly ground black pepper
1/2 teaspoon sea salt
2 small (3 pound) chickens, cut into eighths (skin removed, optional)
16 ounces tomato sauce
6 ounces tomato paste
1 cup, added water


Set the EPC *to sauté/brown mode. Add the canola oil, then the sliced onion and minced garlic. Sauté until the onions are slightly caramelized, stirring occasionally with a heat resistant spatula. Add the mushrooms and continue cooking until the mushrooms are soft. Turn off the EPC.
Remove the vegetables from the EPC pot and place in a medium bowl. Set aside. Place the flour in a large casserole dish. Add the onion powder, garlic powder, paprika, freshly ground black pepper and salt. Stir to blend.
Add the one cup of added water to the EPC pot. Scrape the bottom of the pot with a heat resistant spatula to remove any additional browned bits that may be stuck to the bottom. Place a rack in the EPC pot.
Dredge each piece of chicken in the flour until completely coated. Set the coated chicken on the rack in the EPC pot. Repeat with the remaining pieces, stacking them evenly.
Cover the chicken with the tomato sauce. Top with the mushrooms and onions.
Lock the lid and close the pressure valve. Cooking using manual high pressure mode for 20 minutes. Naturally release the pressure for 15 minutes, then manually release the pressure.
Remove the chicken and rack from the EPC pot. Stir the tomato paste into the remaining hot sauce until it is completely blended. Serve the chicken hot, topped with sauce, mushrooms and onions. *EPC=Electric Pressure Cooker


This is a wonderful Shabbos entree.  Make it ahead and keep warm or rewarm in the oven or warming drawer. We have tried it with all thighs as well. Excellent!


Are you considering purchasing an Instant Pot or Pressure cooker? Check out our recommendations below:


Some gourmet chefs will shy away from the Instant pot because they prefer layering flavor into their dishes to allow them to develop flavor over time using slow cooking techniques, however, these tools are great for cooking food quickly while achieving great flavor in your home kitchen. This, however, is debated by culinary masterminds.

I will save you time trying to understand the science behind the pressure cooker vs. the instant pot. The main difference is that the pressure cooker can become more pressurized than the instant pot which achieves an even faster cook time. 

If you are looking to buy a pressure cooker or an Instant Pot, I would recommend this consideration before spending a sizable chunk of money on your new exciting kitchen gadget.


Define your cooking goals!

There are certain cuisines that rely heavily on pressure cookers. To achieve the flavor of specific regional cuisines you may need to use a pressure cooker. Take Dhamaka (not kosher) for an example; it is a popular Indian restaurant in NYC that heavily relies on pressure cookers to create their famous dishes such as their pressure-cooked chicken pulao, goat neck dum biryani, and gurda kapoora. The owner of the restaurant states that his pressure cookers are essential to maintaining the integrity of his dishes.

Popular chefs, such as Heston Blumenthal claim that pressure cookers allow him to achieve certain flavors in his dishes that he would not be able to achieve otherwise. 


If you are trying to mimic the flavors of specific regional dishes that call for pressurized cooking, you may want to purchase a traditional pressure cooker.

If not, and you are looking for automation and a bit more mindless cooking, the Instant-Pot is a great option. It is as simple as dumping your ingredients into the gadget, pressing the cook button, and coming back to a fully cooked dish. 

So, which one will you choose? After reading TONS of reviews and having multiple in-depth conversations with inside sources, I have compiled a list of options I proudly stand behind. 



Instant Pots 

The Instant Pot brand has four options. We recommend 2/4. 


#1  Duo Evo Plus (Amazon) 

If you are looking for pure ease of use and the fastest cook time, the Duo Evo Plus is your answer. 

This model claims to be a pressure cooker, rice cooker, slow cooker, yogurt maker, sous vide, sauté, food warmer, bake, stockpot, steamer, but all I really care about is the pressure-cooking feature.

The Duo Evo Plus cooks the fastest, has 48 preset cooking options, has better handles than any other model for handling, and my favorite feature, a steam diffusing cover that automates the scary step of releasing the pressurized steam from your Instant Pot. 

*If you are feeding a family of 4-5 people then the 8-quart option is your best bet.

Click here to buy: Duo Evo Plus (Amazon) 


#2 Duo Nova (Amazon)

If the size of your meal is a priority, there is only one model that offers a 10-quart option, the Duo Nova. 

This model only has seven cook features, pressure cooker, slow cooker, rice cooker, steamer, sauté, yogurt maker, sterilizer, and warmer, but again, all I care about is the pressure-cooking feature.

Click here to buy: Duo Nova (Amazon)


*Both options have raving reviews! Just remember, learn how to use the machine before using it. There have been serious injuries caused by the misuse of this product. 


Pressure Cookers

Out of the many reviews, we read online, America’s test kitchen has done the most thorough job testing and explaining which stovetop pressure cookers you should purchase.  


There are four things to look out for in a pressure cooker. 

  1. You want it to be able to reach the listed pressure capacity.
  2. You want it to be stainless steel because other metals will leave a metal taste in your food. 
  3. You want no curves in the body of the pot.
  4. For an even cook, you want the pot to have a thick metal base.



#1 Fissler Vitaquick Pressure Cooker (Amazon)

For those who are looking to invest a bit into their kitchen gadgets, this high-quality Fissler Vitaquick stainless steel stovetop pressure cooker is your best all-around option according to America’s test kitchen. 

Click here to buy: Fissler Vitaquick Pressure Cooker (Amazon)


#2 Presto Stainless Steel Pressure Cooker (Amazon)

If you are on a budget but are looking for the best all-around stovetop pressure cooker, America’s test kitchen recommends the Presto stainless steel pressure cooker.

Click here to buy: Presto Stainless Steel Pressure Cooker (Amazon) 


*This is not a sponsored post. All recommended products are Koshereye tested. We hope to only provide you with amazing Kosher products and recipes. Koshereye may make a small commission if you purchase a product through our Amazon links.